2008/9/3 Hans de Goede <j.w.r.degoede(a)hhs.nl&gt;: nes-ntsc review is BZ #458085 :) David Timms asked to maitaint all *-ntsc packages. Xavier Lamien according to http://lists.rpmfusion.org/pipermail/rpmfusion-developers/2008-April/0004... http://rpmfusion.org/InitialPackageMerge Xavier Lamien according to http://lists.rpmfusion.org/pipermail/rpmfusion-developers/2008-April/0004... http://rpmfusion.org/InitialPackageMerge Xavier Lamien according to http://lists.rpmfusion.org/pipermail/rpmfusion-developers/2008-April/0004... http://rpmfusion.org/InitialPackageMerge Untaken Xavier Lamien according to http://lists.rpmfusion.org/pipermail/rpmfusion-developers/2008-April/0004... http://rpmfusion.org/InitialPackageMerge XulChris http://rpmfusion.org/InitialPackageMerge untaken Xavier Lamien according to http://lists.rpmfusion.org/pipermail/rpmfusion-developers/2008-April/0004... http://rpmfusion.org/InitialPackageMerge snes-ntsc should go to Fedora with sms-ntsc and nes-ntsc. Xavier Lamien according to http://lists.rpmfusion.org/pipermail/rpmfusion-developers/2008-April/0004... http://rpmfusion.org/InitialPackageMerge MarcBradshaw http://lists.rpmfusion.org/pipermail/rpmfusion-developers/2008-August/000... http://rpmfusion.org/InitialPackageMerge Xavier Lamien according to http://lists.rpmfusion.org/pipermail/rpmfusion-developers/2008-April/0004... http://rpmfusion.org/InitialPackageMerge Xavier Lamien according to http://lists.rpmfusion.org/pipermail/rpmfusion-developers/2008-April/0004... http://rpmfusion.org/InitialPackageMerge Untaken Xavier Lamien according to http://lists.rpmfusion.org/pipermail/rpmfusion-developers/2008-April/0004... http://rpmfusion.org/InitialPackageMerge LinusWalleij http://rpmfusion.org/InitialPackageMerge MarcBradshaw http://lists.rpmfusion.org/pipermail/rpmfusion-developers/2008-August/000... http://rpmfusion.org/InitialPackageMerge Xavier Lamien according to http://lists.rpmfusion.org/pipermail/rpmfusion-developers/2008-April/0004... http://rpmfusion.org/InitialPackageMerge It would be nice to hear a word from these packagers :) Bye, Andrea.

I am, but I am not that fast as the others, usually ;-) the problem with qmmp-plugins-freeworld lies in the updated ffmpeg headers ... since it is quite a pain to try to resolve the compilation issues via submitting new versions, I was waiting for the resolution of the mockbuild issue ... I saw some temporary solution from Dan Horak on Tuesday, will try that ASAP (read: sometime this week) K.

Thorsten Leemhuis wrote: Actually (I need to write a blog post about this and let the world) Sept 1st I've started working for RH on the installer team, so I will be having and using RHEL on my machines from now on and thus I could try (I say try for time reasons) to maintain my packages for EPEL too, for now please continue importing them. I think it would be good for me to still be in the loop for the gstreamer packages, gstreamer packages are nasty because newer upstream gstreamer-foo packages often require a newer base gstreamer then we have in Fedora / EPEL, this is for example why I have different gstreamer-foo versions in F-8 then in F-9 / devel. As for the owner ship, many of the listed packages are not much use on EPEL, so they shouldn't be done on EPEL at all I think, shall we co-maintain the ones which are usefull? Regards, Hans

Thorsten Leemhuis wrote: Thanks. Ack, I think they are going to be a pain (for RHEL), ah well. ACK. Regards, Hans

Hans de Goede wrote: Hans: my ears pricked up when you said that... if you still have time, the first package review request is over at: https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=458085 Note that this includes a version update to current {but old version}, with a .so bump. After reading various Fedora, suse, debian info on sonames etc, whether I have done the correct thing is not clear to me. So if you do take a look, make sure I didn't do something silly there. I attached a diff from the orig dribble package, in case that makes it easier. I planned to get nes*ntsc in first, since Andrea's package needs it, and learn what I can from the review before applying similar to the other *ntsc's. DaveT.

2008/9/3 Andrea Musuruane <musuruan(a)gmail.com&gt;: BTW, even if I solve these, we'll be unable to build it because of missing BR: libcapsimage-devel. Bye, Andrea.

Am Mittwoch, 3. September 2008 schrieb Thorsten Leemhuis: I've built it for devel a few minutes ago (build id: 720). Tomorrow I'll test which version I use for F-8/F-9 (there's been some build and runtime issues in the past). Sebastian

2008/9/5 Thorsten Leemhuis <fedora(a)leemhuis.info&gt;: It seems Hans: http://rpmfusion.org/InitialPackageMerge?action=recall&rev=67 Bye, Andrea.

On 05.09.2008 14:34, Hans de Goede wrote: /me confused by all that /me seems to miss something here Note that libmss != libmms /me looks closer http://hansdegoede.livejournal.com/1755.html mentions a libm*s*s in the "From livna:" section, but it seems libm*m*s is meant. Seems the same typo was done in CVS, as there are both libmss and libmms. So I suppose libmss can simply be removed from CVS? CU knurd

Avidemux has a ppc build error that's been bugging me... If you don't mind, I'd like to excludearch ppc{,64} for now just to get it initially into the rpmfusion repositories, then I'll do some more searching for a fix. I don't have a ppc machine to test with so I it's my only strategy is basically trial and build-error ;) As for dvdstyler, I attempted to get it to work with the newest version but since it requires a version of wxsvg linked to ffmpeg, it doesn't build so I guess I'll revert & build the old version (1.5.x) this weekend. Stewart On Wed, 2008-09-03 at 19:06 +0200, Thorsten Leemhuis wrote:

On 06.09.2008 12:00, Hans de Goede wrote: I don't like it very much -- it's quite easy to forget fixing ppc and reverting the ExcludeArch later. Then ppc might stays excluded for weeks or event months -- that's IMHO not what we want. That's what I wanted to suggest as well. (David CCed) CU knurd

On 06.09.2008 20:03, David Woodhouse wrote: I tend to partly disagree and agree with this: Here's why I do partly disagree: I don't like the idea with manually maintained "ExcludeArch tracker bugs" in Bugzilla much, as that IMHO is error prone and easily forgotten. Going to bugzilla and filing new bugs just for tracking is also something that a lot of people don't like much and thus forget on purpose or by accident. OTOH those ExcludeArch tracker bugs help those interested in a particular arch to check for packages that need fixing. That is really important. So we IMHO need those bugs, but also make sure that they are maintainted properly. Maybe the ExcludeArch bugs and tracker bugs work just fine as long as there is a script (started once a week by cron) that checks the packages for use of ExcludeArch or ExclusiveArch and yells if no bugs are found? Maybe something like this could work: Enforce a rule that the Bug number needs to be on the same line with a specific keyword. E.g. like this: ExcludeArch: ppc64 # ExcludeArchBug: 734 That way two simple grep call from a full cvs checkout will find all the packages with a ExcludeArch/ExclusiveArch: $ grep -e ^ExcludeArch -e ^ExclusiveArch */{devel,F-9,F-8}/*.spec | sort k9copy/devel/k9copy.spec:ExcludeArch: ppc ppc64 k9copy/F-9/k9copy.spec:ExcludeArch: ppc ppc64 lxdream/devel/lxdream.spec:ExclusiveArch: %{ix86} x86_64 lxdream/F-8/lxdream.spec:ExclusiveArch: %{ix86} x86_64 lxdream/F-9/lxdream.spec:ExclusiveArch: %{ix86} x86_64 mythtv/devel/mythtv.spec:ExcludeArch: ppc64 mythtv/F-8/mythtv.spec:ExcludeArch: ppc64 mythtv/F-9/mythtv.spec:ExcludeArch: ppc64 # ExcludeArchBug: 734 zsnes/devel/zsnes.spec:ExclusiveArch: i386 zsnes/F-8/zsnes.spec:ExclusiveArch: i386 zsnes/F-9/zsnes.spec:ExclusiveArch: i386 With a second call you are able to find all those without a bug: $ grep -e ^ExcludeArch -e ^ExclusiveArch */{devel,F-9,F-8}/*.spec | \ sort | grep -v ExcludeArchBug k9copy/devel/k9copy.spec:ExcludeArch: ppc ppc64 k9copy/F-9/k9copy.spec:ExcludeArch: ppc ppc64 lxdream/devel/lxdream.spec:ExclusiveArch: %{ix86} x86_64 lxdream/F-8/lxdream.spec:ExclusiveArch: %{ix86} x86_64 lxdream/F-9/lxdream.spec:ExclusiveArch: %{ix86} x86_64 mythtv/devel/mythtv.spec:ExcludeArch: ppc64 mythtv/F-8/mythtv.spec:ExcludeArch: ppc64 zsnes/devel/zsnes.spec:ExclusiveArch: i386 zsnes/F-8/zsnes.spec:ExclusiveArch: i386 zsnes/F-9/zsnes.spec:ExclusiveArch: i386 (Note that mythtv/F-9/mythtv.spec is missing here). That of course should happen not only in RPM Fusion; instead, it should be in the Fedora Packaging Guidelines and then we will use it just the same way in RPM Fusion. Comments? CU knurd

Hi! /me again! On 03.09.2008 19:06, Thorsten Leemhuis wrote: Here is a updated list with a bit more details; created with a simple script (attached, use at your own risk). === free === andreas [AT] bawue.net | comical not found in free-devel andreas [AT] bawue.net | comical not found in free-F-8 andreas [AT] bawue.net | comical not found in free-F-9 chris.stone [AT] gmail.com | gltron not found in free-devel chris.stone [AT] gmail.com | gltron not found in free-F-8 chris.stone [AT] gmail.com | gltron not found in free-F-9 dtimms [AT] iinet.net.au | gcube not found in free-devel dtimms [AT] iinet.net.au | gcube not found in free-F-8 dtimms [AT] iinet.net.au | gcube not found in free-F-9 dtimms [AT] iinet.net.au | madplay not found in free-devel dtimms [AT] iinet.net.au | madplay not found in free-F-8 dtimms [AT] iinet.net.au | madplay not found in free-F-9 eric.tanguy [AT] univ-nantes.fr | libdlna not found in free-devel eric.tanguy [AT] univ-nantes.fr | libdlna not found in free-F-8 eric.tanguy [AT] univ-nantes.fr | libdlna not found in free-F-9 eric.tanguy [AT] univ-nantes.fr | ushare-freeworld not found in free-devel eric.tanguy [AT] univ-nantes.fr | ushare-freeworld not found in free-F-8 eric.tanguy [AT] univ-nantes.fr | ushare-freeworld not found in free-F-9 jon [AT] fedoraunity.org | compat-plone not found in free-devel jon [AT] fedoraunity.org | compat-python24-elementtree not found in free-devel jon [AT] fedoraunity.org | compat-python24-feedparser not found in free-devel jon [AT] fedoraunity.org | compat-python24-imaging not found in free-devel jon [AT] fedoraunity.org | compat-python24-libxml2 not found in free-devel jon [AT] fedoraunity.org | compat-python24-lxml not found in free-devel jon [AT] fedoraunity.org | compat-python24 not found in free-devel jon [AT] fedoraunity.org | compat-python24-setuptools not found in free-devel jon [AT] fedoraunity.org | compat-zope not found in free-devel kwizart [AT] gmail.com | smpeg not found in free-devel kwizart [AT] gmail.com | smpeg not found in free-F-8 kwizart [AT] gmail.com | smpeg not found in free-F-9 kwizart [AT] gmail.com | vlc not found in free-F-8 lxtnow [AT] gmail.com | dvd-slideshow not found in free-F-8 lxtnow [AT] gmail.com | dvd-slideshow not found in free-F-9 lxtnow [AT] gmail.com | rpmfusion-release not found in free-devel lxtnow [AT] gmail.com | rpmfusion-release not found in free-F-8 lxtnow [AT] gmail.com | rpmfusion-release not found in free-F-9 lxtnow [AT] gmail.com | streamdvd not found in free-devel lxtnow [AT] gmail.com | streamdvd not found in free-F-8 lxtnow [AT] gmail.com | streamdvd not found in free-F-9 lxtnow [AT] gmail.com | yabause not found in free-devel lxtnow [AT] gmail.com | yabause not found in free-F-8 lxtnow [AT] gmail.com | yabause not found in free-F-9 musuruan [AT] gmail.com | Nestopia not found in free-devel musuruan [AT] gmail.com | Nestopia not found in free-F-8 musuruan [AT] gmail.com | Nestopia not found in free-F-9 orphaned | KmPg2 not found in free-devel orphaned | KmPg2 not found in free-F-8 orphaned | KmPg2 not found in free-F-9 orphaned | mamory not found in free-devel orphaned | mamory not found in free-F-8 orphaned | mamory not found in free-F-9 orphaned | mupen64 not found in free-devel orphaned | mupen64 not found in free-F-8 orphaned | mupen64 not found in free-F-9 ralf [AT] skytale.net | audacious-plugins-freeworld not found in free-devel ralf [AT] skytale.net | audacious-plugins-freeworld not found in free-F-8 ralf [AT] skytale.net | audacious-plugins-freeworld not found in free-F-9 rdieter [AT] math.unl.edu | gsview not found in free-F-8 rdieter [AT] math.unl.edu | k3b-extras-freeworld not found in free-devel rdieter [AT] math.unl.edu | k3b-extras-freeworld not found in free-F-8 rdieter [AT] math.unl.edu | k3b-extras-freeworld not found in free-F-9 rdieter [AT] math.unl.edu | k9copy not found in free-devel rdieter [AT] math.unl.edu | k9copy not found in free-F-8 rdieter [AT] math.unl.edu | k9copy not found in free-F-9 rdieter [AT] math.unl.edu | kdemultimedia-extras-freeworld not found in free-devel rdieter [AT] math.unl.edu | kdemultimedia-extras-freeworld not found in free-F-8 rdieter [AT] math.unl.edu | kplayer not found in free-F-9 rdieter [AT] math.unl.edu | libtunepimp-extras-freeworld not found in free-devel rdieter [AT] math.unl.edu | libtunepimp-extras-freeworld not found in free-F-8 rdieter [AT] math.unl.edu | libtunepimp-extras-freeworld not found in free-F-9 s.adam [AT] diffingo.com | avidemux not found in free-devel s.adam [AT] diffingo.com | avidemux not found in free-F-8 s.adam [AT] diffingo.com | avidemux not found in free-F-9 s.adam [AT] diffingo.com | dvdstyler not found in free-devel s.adam [AT] diffingo.com | dvdstyler not found in free-F-8 s.adam [AT] diffingo.com | dvdstyler not found in free-F-9 === nonfree === firewing_[AT]_rpmfusion.org | nvidia-kmod not found in nonfree-devel firewing_[AT]_rpmfusion.org | nvidia-kmod not found in nonfree-F-8 firewing_[AT]_rpmfusion.org | nvidia-kmod not found in nonfree-F-9 lxtnow_[AT]_gmail.com | libcapsimage not found in nonfree-devel lxtnow_[AT]_gmail.com | raine not found in nonfree-devel lxtnow_[AT]_gmail.com | raine not found in nonfree-F-8 lxtnow_[AT]_gmail.com | raine not found in nonfree-F-9 lxtnow_[AT]_gmail.com | uade not found in nonfree-devel lxtnow_[AT]_gmail.com | uade not found in nonfree-F-8 lxtnow_[AT]_gmail.com | uade not found in nonfree-F-9 mbarnes_[AT]_redhat.com | gnome-video-arcade not found in nonfree-F-8 musuruan_[AT]_gmail.com | e-uae not found in nonfree-devel musuruan_[AT]_gmail.com | e-uae not found in nonfree-F-8 musuruan_[AT]_gmail.com | e-uae not found in nonfree-F-9 orphaned | mednafen not found in nonfree-devel orphaned | mednafen not found in nonfree-F-8 orphaned | mednafen not found in nonfree-F-9 orphaned | mupen64-ricevideo not found in nonfree-devel orphaned | mupen64-ricevideo not found in nonfree-F-8 orphaned | mupen64-ricevideo not found in nonfree-F-9 packages_[AT]_marcbradshaw.co.uk | doc not found in nonfree-devel packages_[AT]_marcbradshaw.co.uk | doc not found in nonfree-F-8 packages_[AT]_marcbradshaw.co.uk | doc not found in nonfree-F-9 packages_[AT]_marcbradshaw.co.uk | sl not found in nonfree-devel packages_[AT]_marcbradshaw.co.uk | sl not found in nonfree-F-8 packages_[AT]_marcbradshaw.co.uk | sl not found in nonfree-F-9 == MISC == dtimms [AT] iinet.net.au | nes-ntsc not found in free-devel dtimms [AT] iinet.net.au | nes-ntsc not found in free-F-8 dtimms [AT] iinet.net.au | nes-ntsc not found in free-F-9 dtimms [AT] iinet.net.au | smc-ntsc not found in free-devel dtimms [AT] iinet.net.au | smc-ntsc not found in free-F-8 dtimms [AT] iinet.net.au | smc-ntsc not found in free-F-9 dtimms [AT] iinet.net.au | snes-ntsc not found in free-devel dtimms [AT] iinet.net.au | snes-ntsc not found in free-F-8 dtimms [AT] iinet.net.au | snes-ntsc not found in free-F-9 Those are in the process of moving them to Fedora. So should we simply remove those from owners.list and CVS as they will liekly never get imported for RPM Fusion? LinusWalleij | sidplay-libs not found in nonfree-devel LinusWalleij | sidplay-libs not found in nonfree-F-8 LinusWalleij | sidplay-libs not found in nonfree-F-9 Anyone knows if LinusWalleij is still around? Those are still valid: In addition: * I marked some packages as orphaned (see above); I'd say we should remove the packages from CVS and owners.list and thus kill them if no owner for them is found over the next one or two weeks * note that the script assumes that CVS is the correct place; thus it won't detect packages that are missing in CVS CU knurd

On Mon, Sep 15, 2008 at 5:44 PM, Rex Dieter <rdieter(a)math.unl.edu&gt; wrote: Feel free to set it as dead.package in CVS repo -- Xavier.t Lamien -- http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/XavierLamien GPG-Key ID: F3903DEB Fingerprint: 0F2A 7A17 0F1B 82EE FCBF 1F51 76B7 A28D F390 3DEB

2008/9/23 David Timms <dtimms(a)iinet.net.au&gt;: They are still in testing. Can you move at least nes-ntsc to stable? Thus I'll be able to build Nestopia :) https://admin.fedoraproject.org/updates/nes_ntsc-0.2.2-1.fc9 Bye, Andrea.

2008/9/23 Thorsten Leemhuis <fedora(a)leemhuis.info&gt;: Let's follow the usual path. There is no rush :-) Bye, Andrea.

Thorsten Leemhuis pisze: I could pick up mednafen, please set up the necessary acls. Why is this nonfree though? License tag says GPLv2+ Regards, Julian

Thorsten Leemhuis pisze: Let's wait with that. Hans, it was you who put that as nonfree, care to explain? Julian